NO CHILD IS SAFE!!
Sights & Sighs
Life, musings, passions, visions, dreams...
Sunday, November 15, 2026
NO CHILD IS SAFE!!
SMELL
SMELL
It was a smell of blood
of fear
of death
ammonia
thick ammonia
the kind that had no chance to be diluted by mineral water
The smell of soil
termite hill soil
Recently dug
of rain
that drip drip drips
cold painful drops
that hit you and seem to sink into the skin
in the evening dusk
as you rush off
it was a smell of darkness
deep deep fathomless darkness
charcoal and darkish purple
a smell of feaces
blund ugly disgusting
it was a smell.of crime
horrendous crime
fearful
emotionless
death
it was a smell of death
Friday, October 30, 2026
SOME PEOPLE
SOME PEOPLE
Some people who come into your lives
And never leave them the same.
It is their presence - however stubborn, however cheeky –
It is their laughter - however loud, however weird or soft –
It is their touch - however light or rough
It is their stories - however sad, however happy
It is their smell - however subtle, however projective –
It is in their stare – however sharp, however shy or coy
It is in their look – however intense, however quintessential
It is in their taste - however sweet, however tangy
It is in their speech – however fast, however slurred
It is in their thirst however quenching, however filling
It is in their gait – however agile, however sloth or clumsy
It is in their drink - however sloppy, however enticing
It is in their smile – however inviting, however mesmerizing
It is in their hair – however lustrous, however tangled
Hmm… Some people …
_D. R. Ruhweza_
Nairobi Kenya
October 8th, 2026
Tuesday, October 27, 2026
‘Missionary for Justice’ By Justice Fredrick Egonda Ntende
‘Missionary
for Justice’
By
Justice Fredrick Egonda Ntende
St
Luke’s Church, Makoka
Kamuli
District
24.10.2026
Sometime
in 2010 while I was serving as Chief Justice of Seychelles a mutual friend
arranged a meeting with Archbishop Augustine Kasujja, the Apostolic Nuncio to
the Indian Ocean Islands, who was visiting Seychelles to say farewell to the
Government of Seychelles. He had been reassigned to Nigeria. We discussed many
matters in our meeting. Among other things he told me, ‘You are a Missionary
for Justice. Serve God’s people.’ Or words to that effect as I recall from
memory.
Missionary
work is often associated with religious endeavours outside one’s home country.
Who was I to question the Vatican’s Representative who had issued this charge?
Would you be a judge or Chief Justice for that matter and a missionary for
Justice at the same time. Why not? I suppose this question will one day be
settled by a doctoral candidate defending his dissertation. In the meantime, I
humbly accepted this charge from Archbishop Kasujja that I was a Missionary for
Justice. I come today with my family and you my friends to give thanks to the
Almighty for what He has enabled us to accomplish from the date of my birth to
this day, after I retired from public service.
I
have elsewhere told the story of how I eventually got into Judicial service and
maybe for completeness of my story today I will restate it very briefly. The
year was 1991. I had practised law for about 10 years. The Member of Parliament
for Bugabula County, my brother and friend, Professor Wilson Nadiope had passed
on. Some pressure was mounted on me to seek to replace him. I started
consulting. At the time I was the Chancellor of Busoga Diocese. I chose to
visit Bishop Bamwoze and let me know the direction I was about to take. I went
to his home in Naminage. He asked me, ‘Who told you that is God’s plan for
your life?’ I was stuck with no obvious answer. He told me, ‘Let us pray
that the Lord himself will show us his plan for your life.’ We did pray
before we parted and thereafter every evening in our family devotion at home, we
prayed for God’s plan to be revealed to us.
A
few weeks later I was attending a conference at Makerere University when I met
Chief Justice S S Wambuzi and he asked me, ‘Had the Attorney General talked to
me?’ I said, ‘No.’ He then told that they had offered me the post of a Judge of
the High Court of Uganda and they had asked the Attorney General to communicate
the offer and obtain my response before they could ahead. To cut the long story
short I did accept and I was sworn into office in November 1991. As a family we
took it that the Lord had answered our prayer and revealed his plan for my
life.
For
the last 35 years the Lord has often spoken to me about my work and the path I
should take ‘through some people’. One of these I believe was our brother, the
Hon Mr Justice Kityo. Through him I learnt that the position you played at in
the Team Judiciary was simply not determined by the Captain, or Coach; or your
performance but a complicated and intricate architecture. When nothing came of
my nomination by JSC to the Supreme Court in 1994 I was not downcast. I
concentrated on raising my skill and competency levels. I applied and obtained
a professional development programme supported by the USA Government, the
Humphrey Fellowship. I was supposed to commence the programme in 1996 but ‘my
brother’ as he was called ‘tongue in the cheek’ by my colleagues, the Chief
Justice asked me to defer the same for one year and I went in 1997/1998. I concentrated on Human Rights, Courts and
Technology, and Continuing Judicial Education, which equipped me with both
knowledge and skills that would stand me in good stead both at home and in my
missionary journeys abroad.
In
the year 1999 I was deployed to East Timor, Asia, in my first missionary
journey for Justice. Subsequently I was deployed to Kosovo, Europe in 2002 to
2004 in my second missionary journey for justice. Both these societies were
recovering from turmoil. In 2009 I was deployed on my last or rather, third
missionary journey to Seychelles as Chief Justice. In 2008 an Advocate had
chosen to write an anonymous letter to me stating that I was to be appointed
Chief Justice. Indeed hardly 12 months later I was appointed Chief Justice of
Seychelles. I later came to identify the author of that letter but he prefers
for both the letter not to be published nor himself named! I have given him my
word I will not out him.
Had
the appointment to the Supreme Court materialised it would not have been
possible for me to undertake the 3 missionary journeys or tours of duty that I
undertook. Once appointed to the highest court in the land, there is very
limited room for manoeuvre. Indeed God does no wrong.
I
had always intimated to my family and friends that I intended to retire upon
attaining the age of 60 years old as permitted by the Constitution. One evening
our youngest, now Dr Jonathan Kiwudhu, heard of this while we were at dinner
with some guests. He probably had not quite completed Primary School. He put up
his hand and objected. ‘Excuse me Sir. Are you talking about retirement?
What about me? Who will pay my school fees? My siblings may not have enough
money to do so?’ I told him that I had made arrangements to take care of
him even in retirement. He was not convinced. As a result of this intervention
I chose to serve out my full term and comply with God’s plan for my life. Last
year he graduated and this year he completed his internship with National
Referral Hospital, Mulago. I retired on 15.06.2026!
Many
of you may have heard that on the 19th September 2026 at about
9.45am, we, (my aide, Charles Wakabi, Margaret and I), were involved in a
motor accident when our vehicle’s right front wheel disengaged from the vehicle,
flying away, as we were exiting Kla / Ebb Expressway at Kajjansi. The Lord
intervened and we were saved from loss of life or limb! We return the Glory to
the Almighty.
I
thank the Almighty for providing me with many counsellors, (ordained and lay),
the Jethro(s) (Moses’ father-in-law), in my life who were able at
different points in my journey to offer helpful counsel and steer me towards
the fulfilment of God’s plan for my life. I thank the Almighty for the gift of life,
family; my spouse, our parents, our siblings, our children, our grandchildren,
the larger family of which we form part, and you all, we are privileged to call
our friends, with whom we have walked this journey so far. And I have hope with
whom we shall walk the rest of our journey.
Where
I have failed the blame lies squarely with me and I seek God’s forgiveness and
mercy.
I will end with the words of the Psalmist, in Psalm
116 verses 12 to 13.
‘12.
What shall I return to the Lord for all his goodness to me?
13.
I will lift up the cup of salvation and call on the
name of the Lord.’
I thank you all, not only for listening to me, but for
joining us, as a family and friends, as we return thanks to the Lord for his
goodness to us.
May the Almighty Bless you all.
Fredrick
Egonda Ntende
St
Luke’s Church, Makoka
24.10.2026
Tuesday, September 15, 2026
Ne bis in idem in the context of the ICC cases arising from the situations in Africa.
Ne bis in idem in the context of the ICC cases arising
from the situations in Africa.
By D.
R. Ruhweza
Gaiane Nuridzhanian’s The
Principle of ne bis in
idem in International Criminal Law examines the common law principle of double jeopardy
as established in the Rome statute under Article
20 as a legal principle. This Statute establishes the International
Criminal Court (ICC) and in its Article 20 prohibits it from persecuting a person for conduct
previously persecuted by
another court, where the earlier
proceedings were conducted independently or impartially and were not
intended to shield the accused from criminal responsibility for crimes within
the ICC’s jurisdiction. In explaining this principle, Gaiane makes use of ICC cases
arising from Africa
and explains how the existing
law on ne bis in idem
as well as the phrasing
of Article 20 have played a
role in the understanding and application of the principle.
Gaiane, in her introduction, establishes that the main purpose of the
principle is to protect the individual as it serves to “spare the accused the burden of a repeat trial”, protect
them from “unnecessary harassment and uncertainty”
and “safeguard their liberty” once they have already faced trial for the
matter. Additionally it serves to restrict
the state's power over an individual, ensure
the finality of judicial
decisions, and maintain public confidence in the criminal justice system.
An idealistic picture
is painted by the purpose of the principle but this has only been partially fulfilled in regards to cases arising from the situations in Africa. The wording of Article 20 is to the effect that the
protection promised by the principle is not absolute
but rather balanced
against other interests
which are often affected
by the exact circumstances of the prior proceedings as well as the specific
rule under which the article is being applied.
Gaiane relays that the court considers, in relation to the prior proceedings;
the finality of the prior judicial decision, the type of court and the
genuineness of the proceedings. In regards to the specific rule,
she highlights the jurisdiction in question, that is to say intra-jurisdictional vs. inter-jurisdictional, as well as same
crime vs. same conduct.
The
ne bis in idem
is addressed in this book within the context of the ICC cases arising
from the situations in Africa following the specifications in Article 20
and I shall review these below.
Article
20(1) embodies the
intra-jurisdictional aspect of the ne bis
in idem principle, as it applies within the ICC itself, barring
retrial of persons
already tried by the ICC. The author lays down the conditions necessary
to apply this section to include a trial of a person before the ICC, a prior
conviction or acquittal by the ICC, the finality of the prior conviction or
acquittal and the same conduct forming the basis of the crimes. The triggering of the principle relies
on these conditions and the termination
of the case before without a conviction or acquittal would have the opposite
effect. In consideration of this provision, the author makes reference to the
cases of Prosecutor v. William Samoei Ruto and
Joshua Arap Sang as
well as The Prosecutor v. Uhuru Muigai
Kenyatta
where the charges were vacated midtrial and withdrawn pre-trial respectively,
hence preventing the ne bis in idem principle from applying. Finality
after the determination of merits was not met in these cases since there is no
conviction or acquittal, therefore the accused persons in these cases are
liable for retrial before the ICC. Indeed, the protections afforded by the principle
to persons are in such circumstances unavailable, specifically, politically
charged cases with external interference may block judicial closure and leave
the affected persons available for retrial at a later date. Whereas this may be
applied to ensure justice of affected persons, one must consider the effect of
stretching the ne bis in idem
principle’s boundaries through retrials which undermine its spirit as
elucidated by Jean
Paul Pierini.
Notably the cases handled in the ICC arising from African situations are
usually politically charged and may be difficult to handle in the domestic
courts due to aspects like limited evidence and witness intimidation. The
principle ensures that the accused is dealt with accordingly even if the first
trial is dismissed.
Article 20(2)
brings forth the inter-jurisdictional rule, applying between the ICC and a
national criminal court of a state party. This rule prohibits a person from
being tried by another court for a crime referred to in Article 5 of the Rome Statute for which that person has already
been convicted or acquitted by the ICC. Gaiane lays down the conditions
necessary for this provision to apply, with the more contentious one being,
“the use of the term ‘crime’ in Article
20(2), in contrast with the term ‘conduct’ in Article 20(1) and (3), suggests that the ne bis in idem rule in Article
20(2) bars trial for the same offence rather than for the same conduct” (Nuridzhanian, p. 93). Conduct refers to the acts
or events underpinning the charges while the crime refers the specific legal
offence such as those highlighted in Article
5. The difference in the wording of the provisions raises concerns on how
it undermines the principle’s goal of protecting persons from double jeopardy
since they could stand to be retried in domestic courts for the same conduct
amounting to different crimes recognized by the ICC and the domestic courts.
The author demonstrates this using the case of Prosecutor v. Katanga, where following his conviction by
the ICC for crimes committed in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), the
accused faced charges in DRC for crimes allegedly committed before his trial at
the ICC. While reviewing DRC’s prosecution under
Article 108 it was established that the ne
bis in idem principle was not violated, owing to the legally distinct
nature of the charges being brought against him in the domestic court. Notably
the narrowing of the principle’s scope was as a result of the use of the term
“crime” even though the acts targeted by the domestic prosecution were closely
related to the matters handled in the ICC case.
As explained by the author, the
approach taken in Article 20(2)
seems to indicate a level of respect towards state’s discretion in legally
characterising criminal conduct over which it has jurisdiction. The view herein
is that the provision limits the individual's interest in not being tried twice
in favor of the state's interest in exercising its sovereign criminal
jurisdiction. Given the existing political climate in various African states
however, this position puts to question the validity and availability of the
principle’s protections to persons especially in regards to human rights
concerns. Currently the statute presents a tricky balance between state and
individual interests, with the promised individuals’ protections being
secondary concern. There’s therefore a need to harmonize the terminology used
in the statute or enhance the ICC oversight to control and mitigate successive
prosecutions.
Article 20(3) is
similarly concerned with the inter-jurisdictional rule which bars the ICC from
trying a person, with respect to the same conduct, who has already been tried
by another court for conduct also proscribed under Articles 6, 7, 8, or 8 bis of the Rome Statute. This
provision also provides the exceptions to the ne bis in idem rule which
permit an ICC trial if the prior domestic proceedings were for the purpose of
shielding the person from criminal responsibility or were not conducted
independently or impartially in accordance with due process norms and were
inconsistent with an intent to bring the person to justice. Much like the
previously discussed provisions, the ne
bis in idem principle enshrined herein requires the prior judicial
proceedings to have resulted in a final decision on the person's criminal
responsibility and the author demonstrates this using the case of
Prosecutor v. Saif Al-Islam Gaddafi. The author argues that this provision uses “conduct” to bar ICC
trials for acts previously tried domestically and allowed the ICC to assess the
genuineness of Libya’s domestic trial of Saif Al-Islam Gaddafi. The ICC’s
evaluation focused on whether Libya’s judicial proceedings had resulted in a
final decision to the merits, thus acquiring the res judicata effect,
and that they were not intended to shield Gaddafi from accountability for
crimes against humanity. A pivotal point in this assessment was the lack of
finality in regards to the judicial proceedings in the domestic courts,
removing the accused from the protection of the ne bis in idem principle. In her assessment Gaiane emphasizes that Article 20(3) supports the ICC’s
complementary jurisdiction by allowing intervention when domestic courts are
unwilling or unable to prosecute genuinely. She notes that the Gaddafi case in
specific illustrates how Article 20(3)
balances state sovereignty with international accountability, particularly in
African post-conflict settings.
It should be noted however that the
strict requirement of a final decision in the domestic proceedings so as to
trigger the ne ibis in idem principle provides the ICC with a wide berth
to override domestic decisions which ultimately undermines state sovereignty as
seen in the Gaddafi case. It could be argued that by applying this provision
the ICC unfairly penalizes post-conflict states with limited judicial capacity
by undermining their judicial processes. Persons that haven’t received final
judgements are open to retrial at the ICC even when they’ve undergone domestic
trials on the same conduct. Notably however the reference to conduct instead of
crime in this provision creates a broader ambit against ICC retrials of
domestically tried matters contrary to the narrow barring put in place in
subsection 2.
Conclusively, while analyzing the ne bis in idem principle as a whole as
discussed by Gaiane, one can appreciate the author’s distinct and clear
analysis of the guiding law and its application to ICC cases arising from
situations in Africa. There’s a clear show of African contextual awareness with
the author clearly acknowledging the various situations giving rise to the
cases arising from the situations in Africa such as in Libya, Kenya and DRC. There
is a need to consider various concerns made by scholars and
the African Union in regards to fairness and selective justice on the part on
the ICC as well as highlight reform proposals relating directly to the
shortcomings relating to ICC cases arising from situations in Africa.
Wednesday, June 17, 2026
Ides of March
_*Ides of March*_
Julius Caeser
Gaddafi
Mussolini
Hitler
Stalin
Shaka Zulu
Or
Jesus Christ
Desmond Tutu
Nelson Mandela
Pastor Noemoller
Mother Teresa
Florence Nightingale
Idi Amin
Bokassa
Samuel Doe
Pol Pot
Mengistu
Herold
Or Billy Graham
Aung San Suu Kyi
Martin Luther King Jr.
Mahatma Gandhi
Thomas Sankara
Samora Machel
Julius Nyerere
Patrice Lumumba
Genghis Khan
Napoleon Bonarparte
Mao Zehong?
Saturday, June 13, 2026
NEVER AGAIN
NEVER AGAIN
Silent voices
Dirtied clothes
Mutilated bodies
Orphaned children
Displaced families
Widowed Mothers
Butchered face
Landless children
Burnt granaries
Blackened huts
Destroyed harvest
Hungered stomachs
Sleepless nights
Tired feet
Frightened humans
Raped Men
Never again!
MR. SIMON BYABAKAMA MUGENYI very GOOD FOR THE JUDICIARY (An old post from 2008)
and to walk humbly with your God. Micah 6: 8 NIV. Remember too that the opportunities for corruption and influence peddling are now greater than before. Play your part well and stand for righteousness!! Recall the words of Mordecai to Queen Esther "For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance will arise for the Jews (Read Ugandans) from another place and you and your father's house will perish. And who knows whether you have not attained royalty ( read the judiciary) for such a time as this?" Esther 4:14. Remember the Scriptures that call you to "Preserve justice and do righteousness (Isaiah 56:1); also Jeremiah 22:3 which says "Do justice and righteousness, and deliver the one who has been robbed from the power of his oppressor. Also do not mistreat or do violence to the stranger, the orphan, or the widow; and do not shed innocent blood in this place. The same advice goes to all the newly appointed members of the Ugandan Bench….





